Sink or Swim: How to Choose the Right Real Estate Team
Resource Library Blog

Sink or Swim: How to Choose the Right Real Estate Team


You need the right support system to get you through those first crucial years of your real estate career. This means the right office, the right team, and the right tools to help you grow.
According to the National Association of Realtors, over 80% of new real estate agents exit the business in their first two years.
It’s understandable. Building your business can take a while to pay off. New agents can go months without a commission check and feel like there’s no light at the end of the tunnel. In order to be in that 20% that succeed, you must select the right brokerage from the start.

National Franchises vs. Independent Real Estate Companies

Deciding which team to join, or if you’ll go with an independent firm or a national franchise is a very important, and very personal decision. Regardless of what you read on a website or have heard from friends in the business, you need to do your own research and consider your personal work style and values. The high rate of failure can largely be blamed on new agents getting in over their head after not spending enough time analyzing their options before committing to a company.
Those first two years need to be spent learning from successful agents, building a business in a culture that supports your own personal values, and seeing exactly what you need to do in order to build your career and reach the next step. Here’s a high-level look at some of the possibilities of real estate firm choices to help you get your mind around the pros and cons of each, and which will ultimately support your personal success.




Starting Your Real Estate Career at a National Franchise

First up, the big players:
Companies like Century21, Coldwell Banker, Re/MAX, ERA, Berkshire Hathaway, Better Homes & Gardens, Keller Williams, the list goes on. Let’s take a look at some of the most common benefits and work styles are prevalent in the largest, most prominent nationally franchised real estate companies.


These are the names you know. They’re the names that most people know. And that in itself is a compelling incentive to join a franchise. Brand recognition takes years of good business and reputation-building to establish, and joining a strong franchise puts all those years of hard work and earned trust instantly in your corner.
In a recent Inman News Study, 80% of agent survey respondents said brand recognition was the biggest advantage affiliated firms have over independent teams, followed by the greater reach afforded by franchise websites and networks, training, and scalable technology.
These large brands are capable of running extensive marketing campaigns that reinforce their mission and value. No doubt you’re familiar with BHHS “Good to Know” Campaign. Can recognize the Re/MAX balloon anywhere, marveled at the Century21 box ads, and the list goes on.
Joining a national brokerage from the start also exposes you to a vast network of experienced agents. Most have a structured training curriculum with classes for new agents, and for continuing education, there are often opportunities to attend conferences and workshops with powerful speakers, top coaches, and educational content.
For some, however, they feel that a national brokerage provides solid initial classroom training, but little in the way of continued support. The thought is that the goal of the brokerage is to bring in as many agents as possible and see who ends up working out. Many offices will provide the opportunity for “floor time” (manning the front desk for walk-ins) but you’re splitting that time between a great number of other new agents, and some feel it doesn’t provide much value at all.

A technology system is typically provided to agents in a national franchise too. After all, these organizations franchise all their systems which include marketing, training, technology, and operational procedures in return for an initial fee and ongoing payments.

Joining one of these firms immediately provides access to enterprise-scale technology with can involve everything from lead generation and a CRM to e-signatures and transaction management.

It’s worth noting, however, that sometimes these offerings are not well-adopted or suited to the style of each agent, and many have griped that large-scale offerings such as these aren’t all they’re cracked up to be. Many also feel that in franchise offices, there are often more technology tools available, but frequently less administrative support.




The overall sentiment on culture, is that the franchises tend to have a more rigid, corporate feel. This can be misleading, however. While there is an organized mission within each franchise, there are significant differences in business practices, structure, and overall culture of each office.
Remember that each office, even offices in the same local market are owned and operated by individuals and can have completely different cultures and practices.

Profiles of Real Estate Franchises

Lead Conversion Real Estate

Each real estate franchise boasts its own mission and unique qualities, and if you decide you want to go the national franchise route, you still have a lot more decision-making to do. From powerhouses like RE/MAX, Century21 and Keller Williams who boast 100,000+ agents worldwide, to smaller companies like Sotheby’s and Better Homes and Garden, there are many different routes to choose.
To help you see the differences in some of the larger franchises, and what you should look for in compensation, level of support, and training resources, here’s a review from Fit Small Business on 3 of the largest franchises, Re/MAX, Keller Williams, and Century21. Smart Asset also created a profile guide for what they deem to be the best top 10 choices for agents, and they share their reasoning for each.

Joining an Independent Real Estate Firm

Independent Real Estate firms have been on a steady rise for the last few years.

According to the 2015 National Association of REALTORS® Member Profile, 59% of all REALTORS® are affiliated with an independent, non-franchised company.

The rise is due to a couple of different factors. Many brokers questioned the value proposition of franchisors (and the fees), and the rise in technology that allows companies to streamline operations at a smaller scale helped spur the resurgence of the independent brokerage model. Having local control of your company’s branding and digital efforts also makes these companies more nimble in today’s rapidly changing business climate.




While many of the national franchises have become household names across the country, the independent brokerages often have a different and decidedly more local focus. This can be a huge win in attracting consumers who are looking for the local expert to help them buy and sell. Independent firms are in charge of their own branding which means they can get creative on the local scene, adapt quickly to local market conditions, and maintain a strong community presence.
This branding spills over (as it should) into the reality of the consumer’s experience. With the smaller size and local control that independent brokerages enjoy, they can created a more customized feel for clients.




Independent firms don’t have franchise training programs to rely on, but many have created their own development programs that have seen incredible success onboarding and educating new agents. They are training for their market, specifically, and can create a very tailored curriculum to set new agents up for success.

Some smaller firms also partner with a local or regional proprietary school for licensing and customized classes. Most firms have some form of training in place, but it’s worth investigating on a case-by-case basis to make sure the type of training suits your learning style and will continue to help you grow and learn.


While teams that aren’t part of a national franchise don’t have access to the technology systems that are part of the company offering, many prefer it that way. Brokers of independent firms are able to choose a system that complements their unique business needs and often agent adoption is higher. Independents don’t typically receive the referral and relocation business that the franchises afford. Nor do they often have the network-wide discounts and other perks that have been negotiated with the large real estate portals. But that doesn’t seem to affect the overall sentiment:

According to Inman’s Independent Brokerage study, 63% of the independent agents felt that they received more leads and support from their broker than those in franchised firms.




Culture is as varied as the size of the teams and brokers who run each independent firm, but there are a few things to note. Independent firms do tend to attract more creative, entrepreneurial agents who contribute to a “less corporate” culture.

Independent brokers are paying attention too. New Deloitte research puts culture, engagement and retention at the top of the challenges facing business leaders. Independent firms tend to be more unique, regionally focused, and younger. Younger companies that put a large focus on culture are seeing a huge payoff, and many Independent brokerages are following suit.

Surprisingly, in Inman’s Study, a unique, thriving firm culture is the biggest attraction for agents, according to 75 percent of the independent brokers who took the survey. That topped access to in-depth coaching (53 percent) and hands-on tech training (53 percent).

The Pros and Cons of Different Types of Real Estate Teams

Of the 55% of respondents who were Independent brokers, more than three quarters had fewer than 50 agents, nearly two thirds had more than 50 agents, and 22% had more than 200. Since there are so many variations of sizes (in both the offices of franchises and independent firms) it bears mentioning that there are some factors for each size worth examining, and some other typical “team formats” to consider.

Here’s a quick and dirty rundown of some of the different types of offices you may encounter to help you through the process.

Large Firms: 200+ active real estate agents

  • Market domination (most agents= most share of the business)
  • Name recognition and market position
  • Typically have years of success and steady growth behind them.


  • Agents can get lost in the crowd
  • Talent is somewhat expendable
  • Lots of competition

Small firms: 20-200 agents

  • Strong team mentality
  • Opportunity for close working relationships and mentoring
  • Unique value prop (geographic area, property type, etc.)


  • Long term vision alignment. Does the firm want to grow or maintain their position
  • Competition for resources, support, and leads

Boutique Firm

  • Usually revolve around a single veteran broker
  • Very specialized and niche-oriented


  • Exclusive
  • Less opportunity for upward movement
  • Unless you’re invited under the broker-in-charge or there is a stellar training program, this is rarely a good fit for a new agent

Top 5 Things to Consider when Interviewing A Potential Real Estate Brokerage

Concept of Hiring Recruiting Interview

No, you’re not the only one who will be interviewed. You need to look at your entire selection process as an interview of each company too. You want to pay attention to key things that will ensure the company is the right fit for you, and ask yourself questions like if the type of support offered is going to be enough for your personal taste, and if the systems and tools available will suit your unique working style.

Lead Generation Real Estate Plan
You’ll need to come away with a good idea of what commission/fee structures are in place at each potential company. Some cover expenses and tools in exchange for a larger share of commission. Others let you keep more and charge a “desk fee.”
Brokers carry the responsibility for each transaction, so money is spent not only on office, space, marketing and branding, but also on insurance. Many large national brokerages have significant spend on ad campaigns, and local brokerages are paying part of their franchise fee to cover that cost. While smaller independent offices might not be spending big bucks on national campaigns, they’re usually active with spend on a local level. In order to cover all these costs, the broker typically takes a portion of each agent’s commission, or a “split.”
New agents will typically have a low split, and as you gain success and experience, the split increases. Most brokers set a certain dollar amount of sales to tip you into the next level of splits, and the norm for successful agents is usually around 80/20.

Questions to ask: How much of my commission will I keep? What is provided in return?

Real Estate Lead Generation
You’re looking for a thriving company to join, so pay attention to their talk of leads and listing inventory. Dig a little deeper and inquire about what sort of listing referral and relocation business you might be able to take advantage of. Make sure that you can get a sense for if the inventory is high quality and will set you up for success.

Questions to ask: Are leads provided to agents? What format are they allotted? What type of listing referral and relocation business is available? Is the listing inventory high quality?

Lead Generation Plan

Technology and Tools:
You need to join a team that is future-oriented and innovative. Technology systems need to be in place to help you get your business off the ground, stay organized, effectively market to your prospects, and help with lead generation efforts.

Take note of what systems are provided, how the office uses them, and if they seem out of date. In today’s digital world you can’t afford to start somewhere that isn’t on the cutting edge, capturing digital business effectively, and streamlining their internal processes with technology.

Questions to ask: What tech tools are provided to agents? Are they out of date? Is there support staff and training? Is their online marketing effective?

Real Estate Lead Generation

From having a strong mentor to enjoying a formal training program, it’s critical to have some type of educational support when you’re starting your real estate career. Look around each office to see if you can get a sense of how agents work together, and listen for details about their onboarding program, continuing education, meeting style and if they work with any real estate coaches.

Questions to ask: What type of formal training programs are in place? Are their internal mentors to learn from? How are agents held accountable and supported in their goals?

Real Estate Lead Generation

Much more intangible and personal, the culture of any office may be hard to determine during your interview process. Focus on basic concepts like if you like the people you’ve interviewed with, do you relate to them and have a similar work style, is the office structure one that you would work well in, and do people tend to work together and support one another, or is there a more siloed approach. Remember to compare everything with the way you prefer to work and try to find somewhere that aligns with your style.

Questions to ask: What is the broker’s vision or plan for this company? What do they stand for? What are their values? Do these align with my own personal goals and values?

Independent firm vs. Franchises: What’s the Right Choice to Start Your Real Estate Career?

We’ve run the gamut on the different type of options to begin your career, but the real key is to take inventory of your personal goals, work style and personality, and find the office that aligns the best. There is no substitute for careful research, and there are pros and cons to each and every office.

With Independent companies you often enjoy more flexibility, lower costs, more of a voice in the company, and a stronger local brand. But, you’re working in a smaller network with potentially less resources, support, and formal training opportunities. Large, national franchises have the vast referral networks and inventories, formalized training and a well-established brand. They provide technology and marketing resources from the get go, but you’ll often have less input, less freedom, higher fees, and some pretty strict limitations on how you market and brand your business.

Just remember to do your homework and you’ll surely make the right choice.




Don't miss the conversation.

Join thousands of real estate professionals and get the strategies you need, straight to your inbox.

Give it a try. It only takes a click to unsubscribe.

Similar Content

7 Ways to Get More Seller Leads (Beyond Just Direct Mail)

A strong seller lead strategy is crucial for a profitable real estate business. Use these tips to go beyond just direct mail campaigns and find new opportunities to score seller leads.

How To - November Graphic


3 Common Problems for Real Estate Agents
(and how to solve them)

Speed to Lead


The Modern Agent’s Guide to Social Media Strategy

Speed to Lead


If you don’t follow up, someone else will. Here you’ll find some surprising numbers about speed-to-lead and learn how YOU can take advantage of missed opportunity ($)

The Essential Guide to Building a Real Estate Business

Ask yourself, do you want to sell houses for the rest of your life or do you want to build a thriving business? In this guide, Jeff Cohn, founder of Elite Real Estate Systems, teaches us how to focus on being a business owner and not just an agent.

Download the Tip Sheet

5 Powerful Business Tips from Steve Harney

Download our Free Guide

The 3 P’s for Winning Listings


4 Steps to a Winning Listing Presentation

It’s time to learn how to land any listing. Here are 4 tried-and-true tips for preparing a listing presentation that wins every time!

Download the Tip Sheet

4 Pillars to Creating & Maintaining a Successful Lead Management Program

7 Tips to Getting Your Agents to Adopt New Technology

They say a tool is only as good as the one who wields it…and this couldn’t be more true with real estate technology. Here you’ll learn how to assure (once and for all) that your agents will adopt the technology that you’ve invested in.

Download the Tip Sheet

Powerful Prospecting Lessons to Build Your Business

Download the Tip Sheet

How to be a Winner in the Real Estate World

How to Structure Your Team for Lead Follow-Up

Lead follow-up is oftentimes what separates the good from the great. In this guide you’ll learn how to structure your team (from the top) for smooth and effective lead follow-up.

Say Hello to Hiring: The Essential Guide to Growing a Team

Expanding your real estate business is an exciting and lucrative time. And in real estate, we know it’s all about your people. Check out this free guide with tips for effective hiring practices.

The Modern Real Estate Chief Marketing Officer

In real estate today it’s not enough to just be great at selling houses. In this guide we’ll cover how and why you should consider investing in a Chief Marketing Officer.


6 Tips for Standing out Against Competitors [Free Tip Sheet]

In real estate, things move fast and the competition doesn’t sleep. So, what are you doing to stand out? In order to be the go-to agent, you need to be one step ahead of your competitors. Start with these 6 quick tips.

Register for the Series

Fill out this form and register for all of our upcoming webinars at once!

Ready to see a demo?

See what BoomTown can do for your business.

FREE: 1-3-5 Goal Setting Template

Turn dreams of success into celebrations of success. Stay on track with our goal worksheet.

Seller Lead eBook

How Top Agents Survive (and Thrive) in a Turning Real Estate Market

What do you do when the real estate market shifts? When the pendulum swings from buyers to sellers (or vice versa) in your market, make sure you’re ready.


Want to handle objections like a champion?
Download our scripts playbook!

Seller Lead eBook


Convert seller leads. Get the best strategies to conquer listings in your market.

The Real Estate Teams Playbook

We partnered with REAL Trends to conduct interviews with thousands of real estate professionals and the industry’s top performing teams. This playbook contains all of their best strategies for starting and growing a team as well as the systems that must be in place to ensure long-term success.